So you think you can dance

Like a meticulously choreographed, rigorously rehearsed dance, the IPL imbroglio is finally heading towards a pre-scripted, dramatic finale.

It started out with the board wanting to use the excuse of governmental investigations into the IPL’s functioning to trim Modi to size, clip his wings a little, put a layer of oversight [that is to say, a governing council in something more than name, one that functions not merely as a rubber stamp] on the functioning of the commissioner (suspended), and get back to business as usual.

Modi’s combative responses to the series of show cause notices [one, and two] and, more crucially, his determined effort to fling mud helter skelter [his claim that Manohar and Srinivasan were dirty and hence could not sit in judgment over him] changed the choreography of the dance: the BCCI at that point figured that he was more trouble than he was worth, and that it could not work with him even in a curtailed role.

At that point, the Board put into motion a series of moves aimed at a predestined conclusion. Step one was the BCCI laundromat kicking into life, with Manohar giving a clean chit to Amin — very necessary, as Amin had been designated as the next head of the IPL with Bharat Patel as his ‘advisor’. Having exercised his authority, Manohar then grandly recused himself from the disciplinary committee that will hear Modi’s case — in one shot, fulfilling half of Modi’s demand while prima facie injecting an appearance of impartiality into the further proceedings.

Srinivasan, who was named with Manohar as an interested party and hence in no position to sit in judgment on Modi, had earlier covered his particular base by saying he had taken then BCCI president Sharad Pawar’s permission to be part of an IPL bid: in other words, the BCCI secretary had sought, from his immediate superior who was himself heavily conflicted, permission to be similarly conflicted — a proceeding possible only in the looking glass world of the BCCI. Besides, he is in any case not a member of the disciplinary committee, so Modi’s strictures against him sitting in judgment are meaningless.

All of that was part of the set up — the BCCI then got into the climactic part of its performance today, with Srinivasan’s ‘rejection’ of Modi’s responses. I so totally love this bit, don’t you?:

“Since Mr Lalit Modi has accused me of being biased against him, after a thorough and careful reading of his explanation against the charges, I have passed an order that it was not acceptable.”

Laugh-out-loud funny, that bit: the first part of the sentence, regarding the accusation of bias, has no bearing on the second half of the sentence, which is Srinivasan’s determination. In other words: Modi says I am biased; let me, in totally unbiased fashion, say he is full of bull. Right.

The final steps of this dance have already been choreographed. Tomorrow, Amin will meet with the franchise holders and, irrespective of an agenda that includes, among other things, rationalizing the norms on player retention, discussing the revised schedule for IPL4 when two new teams enter the mix, and similar issues, the unstated agenda is to clearly signal the changing of the guard, to finally acquaint the franchises with the fact that the Modi era is over, and that they now have a new dispensation to deal with.

Fast forward to July 3. At the Special General Body Meeting, Srinivasan’s ‘rejection’ of the charges against Modi will be taken up. The SGM will ‘determine’ that there is prima facie cause to refer the issue to the disciplinary committee. The SGM will also nominate someone to take Manohar’s place in that committee, and to join Chirayu Amin [see why Manohar had to clear Amin's name? Else, the same objection Modi raised against Manohar, of bias, would apply] and Arun Jaitley in determining the nature of action.

Irrespective of who the third wheel is, that committee will determine that Modi is in gross violation of BCCI guidelines, that a pattern of irresponsible behavior exists, and that therefore he should be stripped of all powers and either retained in the Board as an ordinary member, or expelled altogether — that final determination depending on how Modi acts from here on. Fling more mud, and it is finito; pull in your horns and lie low, and we’ll leave you with some sort of role within the board.

What I don’t understand is this: why stagger this drama out? All the decisions have already been taken. [If Modi's position as IPL commissioner were still in doubt, Amin -- who is one of the troika who will render judgment -- wouldn't be actively stepping into the IPL boss's role with his meeting tomorrow, would he? There is nothing so pressing that it couldn't wait till after the June 3 meeting, and a final determination of Modi's fate].

So why this drawn out charade? For whose benefit is this drama being played out?

PS: Noticed some folks asking about posts relating to the whatever-cup played out in Sri Lanka, where yesterday they played the final before the final. Sorry, folks — haven’t been watching. Largely because I am swamped with some stuff I need to finish before the half yearly deadline, and partly because I found the whole thing immensely boring, and largely pointless. I’ll pass; am off to Chennai on some urgent personal work tomorrow, and will be back at work, and on blog, Monday. Be well, meantimes…

About these ads

65 thoughts on “So you think you can dance

  1. Не могу сейчас поучаствовать в обсуждении – нет свободного времени. Освобожусь – обязательно выскажу своё мнение.

  2. Prem has not been writing on Yahoo either. The ‘Yorker’ in Yahoo has gone silent and no new posts under ‘NRITest’ either. Prem has introduced number of his columnist friends in the Yahoo ‘Opinions’ section but I think most of them are quite boring and don’t attract huge number of hits. I am sure Prem has to start writing himself in order that Yahoo Opinions stays afloat.

  3. На Вашем месте я бы так не делал.
    В этом что-то есть. Большое спасибо за информацию. Вы оказались правы.
    В этом что-то есть. Большое спасибо за помощь в этом вопросе. Я не знал этого.
    Супер!
    проржался норм

  4. The exclusivity clause is to blame, coupled with time utilization clause is PP’s Yahoo contract.

    He shall not blog here till such time as he is employed by Yahoo! Boo Hoo…

      • Dude, if such clause is there its not a gag order, its an enforceable contract! Prem wouldn’t want to run into litigation for this no.

        • that’s what my point is. y would he bother with a contract with such a clause? isn’t he old enough to not give a fuck about shit like that?

    • If that is indeed the case, he could have still written one final one line post saying that he will no longer blog here in near future. After all he did post many times here even after joining Yahoo, so one last post wouldn’t have got him in any more trouble.

  5. Вы абсолютно правы. В этом что-то есть и идея отличная, поддерживаю.
    На мой взгляд тема весьма интересна. Давайте с Вами пообщаемся в PM.
    Я разбираюсь в этом вопросе. Можно обсудить.
    Поздравляю, отличное сообщение
    НЕ ПЛОХО”

  6. With today’s loss against the lankans,am not sure if the selectors should continue to rule out the Dravids and Laxmans from the WC squad.While the youngsters are supposed to bring fresh legs to the fielding,the continued dependence on this squad by itself can prove fatal to India’s chances.Every slot should be chosen only on merit rather than whom MSD fancies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s