All smoke and mirrors

Sandip Roy asks a pertinent question: Do we even ask the right questions anymore?

Back in 2013, NDTV CEO Vikram Chandra tweeted:

“Was Ishrat a terrorist? And does it matter whether she was or wasn’t? Should it affect our approach to a fake encounter?”

Now with the latest accusations hurled by senior bureaucrats alleging a cover-up and affidavit-fixing at the highest levels, the Ishrat Jahan case is back to haunt the Congress High Command. There could be a probe as to who changed the affidavit and why. As there should.

But chances are, in the upcoming political game of gotcha, whether the encounter was fake or not will play second fiddle to whether Ishrat Jahan was an L-e-T operative or not and whether then Home Minister P Chidambaram changed the affidavit or not. Those are very important questions but it does not mean the original question about fake encounters is an unimportant one.

But when patriotism and national security come into the picture, we quickly lose track of the principle at stake, as we have seen at JNU.

Do you even know what sedition is, the Delhi High Court has apparently asked the Delhi Police as it heard the bail application of Kanhaiya Kumar.

That is exactly the right question to ask in the case. Do anti-India slogans, however repugnant, amount to sedition?

Precisely. Read the full opinion piece here. And consider this: All this manufactured outrage, faux anger, “hurt sentiments” — and both sides are equally guilty — serves what end? Simple: It throws up so much smoke, the fundamental issues are lost sight of.

 

 

Advertisements